Foreign Policy
claims in a report entitled “Who
Has Contributed What in the Coalition Against the Islamic State?” that as
of Nov. 11, 2014, Japan had “given more than $6 million in humanitarian aid to
northern Iraq.” Given Japan’s policy preference for checkbook-over boots on the
ground diplomacy, this looked like an extraordinarily low-ball figure. So I
went to the MOFA website and, lo and behold, a September 19 press release
entitled “Emergency
Grant Aid in response to IDPs in Iraq and Syrian Refugees in Lebanon affected
by the ISIL offensive” states that “the Government of Japan decided to
extend Emergency Grant Aid of 22.70 million US dollars (approximately 2.2
billion Japanese yen) to Iraq and Lebanon, in order to provide emergency
shelters and relief items etc. for these IDPs and refugees,” bringing the “total
amount of additional contribution as countermeasures against ISIL” to “25.50
million US dollars, including other assistance which has already set (sic).”
Granted, that still may not be a lot of money as far as the magnitude of the
conflict and its impact is concerned, but it matches up quite well to the numbers
given for other OECD member countries, and there are limits to the amount of cash
that the efforts can absorb.
I
don’t know where Foreign Policy gets
its numbers from, but I don’t really blame them for this particular oversight.
The MOFA webpage with the relevant information can only be reached from four directions;
1) the Japanese-language webpages for counter-terrorism, 2) the Japanese-language
webpages for public communications, 3) the Japanese-language webpages for Iraq
or Syria, or 4) the English-language webpage for “Crime.” Essentially, MOFA is
doing a very poor job of taking online steps to get its contributions recognized
by the overseas public.
Also
troubling is the fact that no one at MOFA seems to be paying attention to Foreign Policy. If they had, someone
would have noticed, or at least checked to see that it had got the facts right.
FP may not be Foreign Affairs, and it
does carry some fluff pieces from time to time, but it has excellent writers
such as Stephen Walt and, more importantly, does carry articles on Japan from
time to time and has a wide readership.
No comments:
Post a Comment